Sunday Runday
On this weekly column, Android Central Wearables Editor Michael Hicks talks concerning the world of wearables, apps, and health tech associated to working and well being, in his quest to get sooner and fitter.
Athletes usually select a coronary heart fee chest strap, armband, or health watch to guage well being and energy. Nevertheless, a comparatively area of interest (and unusual) possibility is carrying wi-fi earbuds with coronary heart fee monitoring. I solely lately heard of this tech and instantly determined to check whether or not earbud coronary heart fee accuracy is sweet sufficient for critical athletes.
After I learn concerning the Sennheiser Momentum Sport, which sends HR knowledge to the Polar Circulate app, I questioned whether or not Polar H10 customers would need or belief an earbud resolution or if this targets extra informal followers.
Some athletes like standalone LTE smartwatches to work out phone-less, however I do not know of any athlete who’d need to go watch-less for exercises, particularly because you’d lose issues like GPS, working kind knowledge, and a quick-glance display. So somewhat than change a health watch, maybe these health earbuds might present extra correct knowledge.
I made a decision to check a number of wi-fi earbuds with coronary heart fee, however the extra I seemed, the extra I discovered one-off, discontinued merchandise like Bose SoundSport Pulse and Jabra Elite Sport. It made me marvel why these manufacturers did not convey HR tech to different exercise earbuds: client apathy or unreliable outcomes?
I examined the Sennheiser Momentum Sport and Anker Soundcore Liberty 4 earbuds in opposition to my favourite Garmin health watch and a COROS Coronary heart Price Monitor throughout a number of runs and walks, to guage whether or not or not I can depend on earbuds for correct exercise knowledge.
Earbud coronary heart fee accuracy take a look at
The Anker Soundcore Liberty 4 solely makes its exercises out there by means of the companion app’s “Wellness” web page. You’ll be able to’t export your exercises to different health apps like Strava and even see your exercises until the earbuds are related. The barebones exercise outcomes web page reveals an HR common, chart, and set HR zones that I could not edit.
In different phrases, Anker’s determination to pressure you to make use of its app makes the info all however ineffective to athletes. Nonetheless, I would already run three miles carrying the Liberty 4, Garmin Forerunner 965, and COROS HRM synced to a different COROS watch, so I did my greatest to interpret the info.
Picture 1 of 2
The COROS HRM decided a 147bpm common throughout my three-mile run. My Garmin Forerunner 965 measured 148bpm; the chart above reveals moments the place it dips extra slowly than the armband when my tempo slows or misses small modifications in coronary heart fee. It usually matches with few errors—what you’d anticipate from a dependable optical HR monitor.
As for the earbuds, Anker calculated a 149 bpm common, which does not sound too imprecise at first look. However wanting on the coronary heart fee graph intently, it has me hitting 167 or 168bpm for sustained stretches throughout my run; neither Garmin nor COROS measured me any increased than 159bpm.
There’s additionally the straightforward proven fact that as I ran with the Soundcore app open, my coronary heart fee appeared to fluctuate way more erratically than my watch or HR strap. It might common out to one thing near the proper consequence, nevertheless it did not go away me feeling assured. And ultimately, the proper earbud — which tracks coronary heart fee — burned by means of its battery way more rapidly than the left.
I switched to the Sennheiser Momentum Sport because it exports to the Polar Circulate app; this meant I might truly evaluate coronary heart fee charts immediately and higher take a look at earbud HR accuracy. To start out, I did an impromptu four-mile stroll with my earbuds and Garmin watch, adopted by a five-mile run.
For the stroll, Sennheiser fell wanting Garmin by 1 bpm; since Garmin typically averages about 1 bpm above my arm and chest straps, that is not a nasty consequence. I did discover a couple of anomalies within the graph the place Sennheiser had my coronary heart fee leaping effectively above my precise effort stage, however usually talking, it adopted my Forerunner knowledge fairly intently.
My run outcomes, for comparability, have been disappointing:
Issues began out swimmingly. Sennheiser as soon as once more had a few elevated blips within the early miles however settled down and tracked Garmin intently by means of the primary 3.5 miles. Then I made a decision to choose up my tempo, at which level the Momentum Sport could not sustain: they averaged about 10bpm decrease, generally solely 5bpm down however often as much as 15bpm off.
Sennheiser completed with a 153bpm common, solely two wanting Garmin’s estimate. That is completely sufficient for an on a regular basis athlete in search of knowledge on burned energy, nevertheless it’s not correct sufficient to make a critical athlete joyful.
I made a decision to do yet another correct take a look at. I used Sennheiser’s match take a look at to verify I had the proper ear cup measurement, placed on my COROS strap and Garmin watch, and did yet another run break up into two actions: one at a sluggish tempo, one a tough observe exercise.
Picture 1 of 2
Think about my intense frustration to find that Sennheiser and Polar did not sync correctly. For each my quick run and observe exercise, the Polar Circulate app stopped receiving new data and locked my coronary heart fee at a set level. I did not discover as a result of I stored my cellphone in my pocket throughout runs.
You would possibly assume that it’s important to hold the Polar Circulate app open, however that wasn’t the case with my earlier exams. Plus, you possibly can see the observe exercise above exhibiting that it immediately began receiving coronary heart fee knowledge close to the top, with my cellphone nonetheless in my pocket. For that transient glimpse, it was extra of the identical: the Sennheiser Momentum Sport was about 10–20 bpm wanting my precise coronary heart fee.
Area of interest for a purpose
I started this earbud coronary heart fee accuracy take a look at completely optimistic about how the outcomes would prove. I had a imprecise sense that my ears would supply a reliable window to my coronary heart, the identical manner you possibly can test somebody’s pulse with both their wrist or neck. As an alternative, I got here away disillusioned.
I by no means acquired any outcomes that steered I ought to belief exercise earbuds as a lot as a health watch; the wonky knowledge jogged my memory extra of good rings, that are correct in excellent situations however can wrestle with correct exercise knowledge and better coronary heart charges. Plus, I missed carrying open-ear earbuds, which really feel a lot safer and extra comfy throughout runs.
The Sennheiser Momentum Sport additionally tracks physique temperature throughout exercises, however that was additionally a letdown.
I used a pro-level temperature sensor throughout a observe exercise in March and found my physique reached a low-grade fever (101ºF / 38.3ºC) at max effort. Sennheiser mentioned my physique warmth by no means rose above 97.8ºF. I believe exterior airflow stored my ear canals cooler than the remainder of my physique and that these earbuds would work higher for an indoor health club exercise.
A weightlifter who hates carrying watches on the health club might get away with carrying coronary heart fee earbuds as an alternative and get respectable outcomes for a normal caloric burn quantity. In any other case, I simply do not see the necessity for this expertise, no less than till one firm can obtain extra constant knowledge.