Design Dilemma: Aesthetics vs. Performance


In September 2021, the short-form video app TikTok turned probably the most downloaded utility worldwide, with 656 million downloads. The app’s success is because of many elements, however arguably crucial is its purposeful interface. Framing the seeming chaos of full-screen movies is an uncluttered grid that customers can effortlessly navigate to succeed in their desired content material. By following a purposeful design method, TikTok has eradicated pointless friction, decreased cognitive load, and created a way of order for its customers.

Aesthetics versus performance is an age-old dilemma for designers, as each are important ideas in UX design. Whereas a visually interesting interface helps customers join emotionally with a product and impacts preliminary person engagement, a seamless person expertise straight impacts how simply customers carry out duties and get what they want out of the product. Ideally, aesthetics and performance would merge seamlessly in digital design, however this isn’t all the time the case. Usually, elements similar to person wants and industry-specific market laws pull designers in a single path or one other.

Having spent the previous 14 years striving to craft user-friendly and visually interesting digital experiences—most lately a Web3 music-sharing cellular app—I perceive this dilemma. In my expertise, whereas aesthetics are vital for attracting customers and making a optimistic first impression, they need to by no means come on the expense of performance, with out which a digital product would lack function and utility. However that doesn’t imply there aren’t circumstances when aesthetics would take heart stage. Let’s talk about.

Aesthetics within the UX Design Course of

Visually pleasing UX design refers to creating person experiences which can be interesting, participating, and fulfilling. This method includes implementing graphic design ideas similar to coloration, typography, whitespace, imagery, and visible suggestions to craft a visible composition. Such an method goals to boost person satisfaction, allow the person to attach emotionally with the product, and convey a recognizable and memorable model presence.

The main elements of aesthetically pleasing UX design include harmonious colors, high-quality imagery, balanced whitespace, readable typography, and others.

There are a number of methods aesthetics contribute to the general person expertise of digital merchandise. Firstly, a visually enticing interface can create a optimistic preliminary impression, attracting customers and inspiring additional exploration. A seminal examine by a staff of MIT neuroscientists discovered that the mind processes visible info inside milliseconds. When customers work together with a web site or utility for the primary time, the fast visible affect considerably influences their notion.

Furthermore, persistently utilized aesthetic parts contribute to shaping and reinforcing a model’s picture and making it memorable. A novel and visually constant web site helps create an enduring impression and a way of belief, making customers extra prone to return.

As well as, customers typically understand aesthetically pleasing designs as usable and environment friendly, even when they may not objectively be so, in line with a pioneering examine of ATM interfaces. Researchers requested individuals to work together with ATMs with totally different designs and located that individuals rated the ATMs with extra aesthetically pleasing designs as simpler to make use of—regardless of related performance throughout all machines. This led the researchers to the conclusion that aesthetic enchantment positively influenced perceived usability.

A Practical Method to UX Design

Performance refers to how properly a product or system works and the way simply customers can accomplish their objectives. Practical concerns of digital design embrace user-centricity, usability, and accessibility. Person-centricity is a philosophy that locations the person or buyer on the heart of product growth. Usability is the convenience of use of the interface’s format and navigation system. And accessibility refers to creating certain customers with totally different ranges of expertise and skill can entry the web site or platform.

The main elements of functional UX design include  consistency, simplicity, task efficiency, visual hierarchy, and others.

Practical UX design prioritizes options that improve usability, simplify duties, and take away irrelevant parts, whether or not it’s a distracting icon, a fancy navigational construction, or pointless animation. This method reduces the cognitive load that may overwhelm customers and trigger them to desert a product. When applied accurately, this design technique can increase person retention and buyer satisfaction, and assist interfaces adapt to evolving applied sciences.

Aesthetics vs. Performance: Selecting a Design Method

Ideally, designers ought to steadiness aesthetic and purposeful design. A traditional instance of this final steadiness is Apple’s iPhone. The interface’s smooth design, intuitiveness, and progressive options, similar to AirDrop for file sharing with close by Apple units, proceed to set it aside from different units.

Each aesthetics and performance are important for profitable digital design. So when designers are pulled in a single path or one other to be able to meet person wants or market laws, which design method ought to they observe?

When to Prioritize Aesthetics

Industries centered on visible content material or advertising are likely to lean towards an aesthetics-first design course of. E-commerce corporations, for instance, typically prioritize aesthetic designs as a result of first impressions and model recognition contribute to their success. On-line style and beauty retailer ASOS is a good instance of an aesthetically pleasing person interface.

ASOS’ desktop site with call-to-action buttons to shop two categories: Trending Denim and Topshop.
ASOS makes use of a mix of brightly coloured graphics and a clear white background to boost its visible enchantment and ease of navigation for customers. (ASOS)

The platform contrasts multicolored shiny graphic parts in opposition to a white background. This distinction helps the person visually soak up the content material by creating a level of separation between web page parts and main the reader’s eye from one place to a different, making the entire studying course of really feel pure and linear.

The model has additionally invested in high-quality photos to showcase its merchandise. In a conventional brick-and-mortar retailer, clients can bodily see and examine product high quality. With out this bodily interplay, on-line product photos are customers’ main reference level. Excessive-quality pictures mimic the in-store expertise as carefully as potential. Clear and detailed photos additionally give consumers confidence and assist them make better-informed buying choices.

Past on-line style, aesthetics play a major position in lots of different industries. Duolingo has a playful interface with a cartoon mascot that appeals to each kids and adults, and embodies the model’s values: Make studying languages enjoyable and universally accessible. Furthermore, daring colours and distinct icons assist customers distinguish between classes and modules, and preserve observe of their progress. The aesthetic design of Fenty Magnificence consists of participating imagery, rollover animations, and splashy movies to focus on the merchandise and create a compelling expertise for the sweetness and skincare model’s buyers.

Nonetheless, aesthetics alone can’t preserve customers engaged. Profitable merchandise additionally depend on wealthy options and usefulness greatest practices, similar to intuitive search and navigation techniques and a seamless checkout circulate. As an example, to assist navigate roughly 85,000 merchandise, ASOS’ cellular customers can make the most of the platform’s Model Match function to take a photograph or add a picture and search ASOS for related merchandise. This visible search device presents a personalised and accessible procuring expertise, notably for customers who wrestle to articulate what they need in phrases however can simply acknowledge it visually. Duolingo employs gamified parts similar to factors, ranges, streaks, and rewards to maintain customers motivated and desirous to proceed studying. Past a visually interesting interface, Fenty Magnificence presents options like a digital try-on for locating the appropriate basis and the choice to guide an appointment with a magnificence knowledgeable.

When to Give attention to Performance

Designers typically prioritize performance when coping with advanced workflows as a result of this method helps simplify and scale back the steps customers should take to perform duties. Such streamlining is sort of all the time a requirement for technology-related services and products. Google’s homepage—and its single enter subject the place customers can enter search queries—is the final word instance of a minimalistic design that eliminates distractions and focuses the person’s consideration on the duty at hand.

One other efficient function for bettering performance and person expertise is an easy name to motion (CTA) that helps fast-track customers to the place they need to go. For instance, if a person visits their “Drafts & despatched” folder in Slack however has no drafts in progress, a brief suggestion and CTA immediate them to begin a brand new message.

The empty state displayed on the “Drafts & sent” page of Slack’s desktop application.
As an alternative of presenting a clean display screen with out prompts, the empty state for Slack’s drafts web page encourages customers to take particular actions. (Slack Applied sciences, LLC)

Within the healthcare, aerospace, and automotive industries, performance typically takes priority over aesthetics to be able to meet stringent compliance laws and requirements, decrease the danger of system failures, and prioritize security. Medical info is inherently difficult to decipher, so readability is king. Accessibility can also be key, and a purposeful design method may help guarantee digital healthcare merchandise are usable for everybody, together with customers with restricted digital literacy abilities and visible disabilities.

There are numerous methods to enhance accessibility and performance, similar to implementing user-friendly info structure and making use of easy language for menu gadgets and navigational buttons. Medisafe, a tablet minder and tracker platform shortlisted for probably the most useful digital remedy award by the Reuters Occasions Pharma Awards USA in 2022, is an instance of wonderful purposeful design in digital well being.

A dosage reminder notification on a Medisafe user’s smartphone lock screen.
Medisafe customers are prompted to take their treatment on the programmed time with a reminder on their smartphone’s lock display screen. (Medisafe)

The Medisafe app emphasizes performance and usefulness by way of an progressive notification system by which customers can mark doses as taken proper from the lock display screen of their smartphones. After they obtain a notification, they merely press and maintain down on it to open the reminder and mark the dose as full.

A Practical Design Case Research: Prioritizing Usability and Person Wants

Every mission is totally different. Right here’s an instance of a time once I prioritized performance within the design course of:

I lately led a mission to design the interface of a decentralized music-sharing app. Our goal was to ship a clear, purpose-driven, and user-centric product, aligning with evolving expectations for decentralized music-sharing within the Web3 period. To attain this, we centered on creating important and simply accessible options.

We wished to make sure the house display screen prioritized key person actions, similar to trying to find music, looking playlists, and accessing profile info. We due to this fact designed a panoramic view of the person’s music library, shared tracks, and engagement metrics.

As well as, we added a personalised categorization system and wealthy search options to make sure customers may uncover and handle their music effortlessly. To make this potential, we designed a means for artists to straight curate their very own style classifications to signify their music extra authentically somewhat than relying solely on studying algorithms. We additionally launched superior search filters that allowed customers to browse music primarily based on the temper or emotion they wished to expertise, in addition to style, artist, and key phrase. These options had been essential for giving customers of our decentralized music app extra management over their music preferences.

No matter whether or not a mission’s focus is on aesthetics or performance, the designer’s final purpose ought to all the time be to create a optimistic and significant expertise for the person. By focusing our efforts on designing key options which can be simple to navigate, somewhat than on design aesthetics, we delivered a extremely usable and user-oriented interface. Our shopper was happy with the result and can quickly launch the MVP in order that artists and listeners can take a look at the app in beta format.

Placing the Proper Stability for Seamless UX

By understanding person wants and market laws particular to an {industry}, designers can craft digital experiences that surpass expectations and improve the person expertise. Sure industries, similar to healthcare or finance, typically prioritize performance and usefulness as a result of essential nature of their functions. Different sectors, similar to on-line retail, place extra emphasis on visually interesting design to create a optimistic first impression and a way of belief and professionalism.

Guaranteeing {that a} product features accurately is essential, as it’s performance that determines the product’s usefulness. Nonetheless, a profitable digital product is one which strikes the appropriate steadiness between a visually interesting design and a user-friendly, purposeful expertise.

Recent Articles

Related Stories

Leave A Reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Stay on op - Ge the daily news in your inbox